MiningMX
MiningMX

Will Gold Fields still sweeten its pitch for Aussie miner Northern Star?

Mike Fraser, CEO, Gold Fields
Mike Fraser, CEO, Gold Fields Picture: Image Philip Mostert

GOLD Fields CEO Mike Fraser said in a presentation earlier this month that, following a month-long roadshow, most shareholders saw the “industrial logic” of the firm’s $23bn bid for Northern Star Resources, Australia’s largest miner.

Yet that doesn’t mean a deal is imminent. “While we believe this has a compelling value proposition for Gold Fields shareholders and for Northern Star shareholders, and remain open for engagement, there’s no certainty of a transaction occurring,” said Fraser after the publication of a third-quarter production update.

Those words sound like talks are stuck on price, as they often are. “The current offer is way off the mark,” a market source tells Miningmx. “Northern Star is doing what it should do: offering to talk but not sell for a song.”

When the proposed takeover of Northern Star was made public on September 14, Gold Fields offered shares and cash equal to A$27 a share. The share component means the offer waxes and wanes with the market: at the time of writing, the offer — in its structure of 0.3125 Gold Fields shares and A$7.25 in cash for each Northern Star share — is worth A$24 a share.

“Deals of this nature typically require premiums closer to 30% … which is well above the current 22% proposal,” says Arnold van Graan, an analyst for Nedbank Securities, in a recent report. “A higher offer is, therefore, quite likely,” he adds.

Another source says: “There will need to be a significant lift in price just to get traction. Suresh [Vadnagra, Northern Star’s new CEO] will be given six months to show some improvements, sell noncore assets and unlock the value from within rather than through Gold Fields.”

Fraser could improve his firm’s offer, but will it be enough to convince Northern Star’s board, which is being refreshed with a new chairperson to be elected this month, to take the money rather than wait for organic improvement? Offer too much, and Fraser risks shareholders mounting the opposition his predecessor Chris Griffith encountered in 2022.

Unlike then, when a rival third party lit up Gold Fields’s tilt at Yamana Gold (and then led to its failure), the bid for Northern Star has a distinct lack of interloper interest.

It’s also worth mentioning that Gold Fields doesn’t have much room for manoeuvre. Net debt doubled in the third quarter after the group seized on recent share price weakness to buy back stock, as Fraser promised he would do.

In addition, the approval of Gold Fields’s C$1.8bn Windfall project in Québec means that the group will start to commit project capex from next year. Fraser said an updated capital cost for Windfall would be disclosed at the annual results presentation in February. Scotiabank is working on C$2bn at least owing to delays in the environmental permit for Windfall.

The Ghana question

Costs rose 27% in the third quarter year on year and while the scale of mining inflation was anticipated in Gold Fields’s annual forecasts, it’s still a hefty leap. Moreover, some of the inflation comes from increased royalties to governments. Those will only increase in 2027, say analysts, who believe the renewal of mining leases for Gold Fields’s Tarkwa mine in Ghana will incur higher payments to Ghana.

Fraser is clearly concerned about Tarkwa, which was worth about 17% of the group’s third-quarter production of 605,000 ounces. “We have no committed timeframe from the government despite there being only six months remaining on the expiry of leases,” he told investors last week.

Matt Greene, an analyst for Goldman Sachs, says: “Our base case remains that the licences are renewed, but with revised fiscal terms [higher royalties from the second quarter of 2027].” But there is jeopardy for Gold Fields. It referred to “increased levels of regulatory activity at Tarkwa”, suggesting heightened government-related interference in the running of the operation.

Asked about this, Fraser said: “It is interesting that it appears the regulators are getting much more active … Certainly, we are not afraid of it because we are quite clear that we are fully compliant … It is just interesting that it is happening at a time when we are in the midst of this latest renewal negotiation.”

Van Graan says Ghana will in all likelihood extend Gold Fields’s permits for Tarkwa. “With these assets you need the long-standing technical know-how and you need the big balance sheets,” he says.

That would appear to be the view of the Ghanaians as well. “It’s not a policy of government to go and take a mine from any foreign companies,” said Emmanuel Armah-Kofi Buah, Ghana’s minister for lands and natural resources, in a recent Bloomberg News report.

But, said Fraser: “This is … not a country that is business as usual at the moment.”

This article first appeared in the Financial Mail.