MiningMX
MiningMX

Gold miners face new test after years of exceptional profits

Investment in gold.Money and Gold
Money and gold bars Investment in gold.Money and Gold Picture: Eugen Wais

THE sharp decline in the gold price may herald the end of almost two years in exceptional profit-making for the metal's miners, but share price corrections lately are giving a misleading impression of the industry's overall financial position, analysts say.

Gold prices are still historically high, and many producers have emerged from the rally with stronger balance sheets and considerable financial flexibility. The more immediate concern is not whether they can remain profitable, but how quickly their earnings could decline.

By Friday, spot gold was heading for its worst weekly performance in eight months, trading around $3,550 per ounce (oz) after losing roughly 9% during the week.

The sell-off has also hit mining shares. JSE-listed gold producers Harmony, Gold Fields, AngloGold Ashanti and DRDGold all recorded sharp declines, reflecting growing concern about the outlook for earnings.

For much of the past two years, rising gold prices more than compensated for increases in production costs. Producers reported progressively higher selling prices, stronger cash flows and improved earnings.

That relationship is now reversing.

Mish-al Emeran, a portfolio manager at Abax Investments, told Miningmx that producers could be entering a period of earnings downgrades after almost two years of upgrades.

Operating costs continue to rise, even as the prices companies receive for their gold decline. This could put considerable pressure on profit margins, although major producers remain a long way from becoming unprofitable.

Emeran said the decline in mining shares was understandable. Lower expected cash flows and earnings growth inevitably affect company valuations.

But have investors overreacted?

"It's difficult to say with conviction whether it's an overreaction," he said.

Much depends on whether investors expect gold prices to recover or fall further.

Still some breathing room

Gold producers are nevertheless in a stronger financial position than they were before the rally.

Emeran said the substantial cash flows generated over the past 12 to 18 months had strengthened balance sheets, giving companies room to withstand weaker prices without immediately changing their spending plans.

"The balance sheets are across the board relatively quite strong," he said.

Major investment decisions are not generally based on short-term price movements. But if the downturn continues, producers may eventually have to reconsider dividends and the pace of expansion projects.

Higher-cost operations would be more vulnerable because they have less room to absorb lower selling prices.

Danie Dorfling, head of business development and marketing at Moore Infinity, also believes the impact will vary between producers.

For South African operations, the rand gold price is particularly important. A weaker local currency can partly offset declining dollar prices, although rising electricity costs, royalties and development expenditure continue to put pressure on margins.

Lower-cost operations generally have more protection against a sustained decline.

For now, falling gold prices do not necessarily mean producers are heading into financial difficulty. But the unusually strong earnings growth that has supported mining shares is coming under pressure.

The next test

The outlook also depends on whether the current selling spreads to other investors.

Joni Teves, a strategist at UBS, said in an analyst note that much of the recent selling appeared to be concentrated in gold futures.

Open interest in gold futures has fallen by the equivalent of more than 6 million oz since the previous week, but holdings in gold-backed exchange-traded funds (ETFs) have remained relatively stable.

But that could change.

Teves noted that investors added about 166 tons to ETFs during the previous quarter, when gold was trading largely between $4,000 and $4,500/oz. Many of those investments are now showing substantial losses.

Whether investors retain their holdings or start selling could influence the next phase of the decline.

Lower prices may encourage physical buying, particularly in China, but Teves said the speed of the fall and uncertainty about US interest rates were keeping buyers cautious.

Dorfling expects gold to remain under pressure over the next three to six months. However, he is cautiously optimistic over a longer period of 12 to 24 months, arguing that central bank buying and broader economic and geopolitical uncertainty continue to support demand.

Teves also believes the longer-term case for holding gold remains intact.

For producers, much depends on whether gold prices recover or remain low. Many have the financial capacity to withstand lower prices for now.

But a prolonged period of weaker prices and rising costs could eventually force them to reconsider their spending plans.